First, what you were planning to do isn't correct. The problem is, to correctly get the preload set, you have to measure the torque at the pinion. Also, you should NOT reuse the same crush collar if so equipped (GM differentials). The preload is measured in inch-pounds (a very small amount Nm). It is basically the turning resistance of the pinion by itself after there is some amount of "squeeze" put on the bearing from tightening the pinion nut. Too much preload and you destroy the bearings in the pinion (after a period of time). Not enough preload and your pinion is too floppy, which causes wear on the gears of the differential, premature seal failure, and the differential is usually noisy during operation.
If you were changing out the seal on a GM differential, this is what you'd need to do:
- Jack up rear of car
- Remove tires
- Remove brakes
- Remove inspection cover
- Remove paddle or pin
- Push in axles
- Remove C clips
- Remove axles
- Remove caps
- Pry out carrier without damaging it or the rear
- Remember which carrier shims go in which side (DON'T MESS THIS UP)
- Remove pinion nut and washer
- Remove yoke
- Remove the pinion seal
- Remove outer pinion bearing
- Remove pinion
- Remove crush collar
- Install new pinion seal
- Install new crush collar
- Install Pinion
- Install Outer bearing
- Install Yoke
- Install Nut and washer
- Tighten the nut just past snug
- Check the preload
- Continue the tighten/check steps until you get the desired preload
- Put all accessories back on the way they came off
- Let the vehicle down of the jack stands
The idea is to sneak up on the preload. If you over-tighten the pinion and create too much preload, the crush collar is then crushed beyond what is usable and you have to start over with a new one.
Some differentials do not have a crush collar, but the check/tighten process is still the same. Remember, this is the resistance measured in in-lb on a free spinning differential (has to be jacked up on stands). You'll have to check for your specific vehicle whether it has a crush collar and what the exact preload is supposed to be.