I brought my 2002 Saturn SL2 in to Nolte's in Oshkosh, WI and had a battery and seal replaced; only when I brought the car into the shop my odometer read less than 23,000 miles and afterwards it read 91,000 miles.

I was able to get records from two places that I had previously brought the car to that clearly tell the true odometer readings, proving that there was no way I was able to put an additional 65,000 miles on the car in that short time period. Any ideas of what I can do?