Some rebar popped a tire (ST205/75R14) on my dual axle 3500lb 26ft camping trailer.

I'm not sure the year or mileage (bought the trailer used last year), but wear suggests the 4 tires have 60% of their life left.

I also have a unused full spare.

Options, in order of decreasing price:

  1. Replace 4 tires. Seems unnecessarily expensive as (a) it's "only" a trailer and (b) I'm not even halfway through their lifetime. (And heck, what if I kill another tire?)
  2. Replace 2 tires on one axle, and have two different pairs.
  3. Use the spare tire, and replace it. The spare's wear doesn't match the other 3 wheels.

What's the recommended approach to take?


If the axles are not driven then there is no real issue of having a part-worn in front or behind a full one.

The problem comes when the axle is driven - specially with some 4wd - as the differentials need to allow for different rolling differences due to corners.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.