3

A friend of mine (he is not my friend anymore) decided to pull a practical prank on my new motorcycle. He pulled the wire of one of the spark plug (my bike has three of them in the cylinder) and let it hanging by the engine case. I cranked up the engine without noticing it and let it idle for a minute before noticing sparks coming out the side from the spark plug cable. It was sparking against the engine case. I reconnected it and rode away thinking it wasn't any harm. Another friend of mine said that this prank could have damaged my starter coil and that spark plug could not be sparking at all. Now I don't notice any change in the performance of the motorcycle but is he right? Could this have done damage to the bike?

2
  • I guess you mean ignition coil instead of "starter coil"? If it works, it probably continues to work... I have had ignition issues with spark going to places it shouldn't on an old car, and none of this damaged the ignition coil. – juhist Jul 14 '18 at 12:11
  • yes I meant the ignition coil. – Sandepp Jul 14 '18 at 13:03
1

No. The reason your other friend incorrectly said that is because if a charged plug was touching a ground (the frame or whatever) that's a short over a device designed to produce a high voltage, which, obviously, could ruin it. However, the plugs cable ends are "highly" female in that there is plenty of rubber to prevent them from accidentally touching a ground. You can't even touch the metal inside the cable with a finger.

From the coil's perspective, the electrical difference between sparking in a spark plug and sparking through the plug cap rubber and onto the engine isn't that much, except it has to go over a much larger air gap distance. The main point is that it isn't being shorted because of the design. Cars (where most of the engineering came from for your motorcycle) are > 100 years old. Engineers thought of this exact situation already and designed accordingly.

That said, you might have died had the loose cable had touched you while you were driving 50 mph. Unlikely you'd be doing that missing a cylinder of power, but that's a bigger concern in my book.

0

Could this have done damage to the bike?

One thing that can happen on all engines having multiple cylinders and a catalytic converter is this:

  1. N-1 cylinders are firing, providing hot exhaust to the catalytic converter
  2. The remaining cylinder is not firing, so the raw evaporated fuel goes to the catalytic converter
  3. The fuel burns in the catalytic converter that's at the reaction temperature
  4. Your catalytic converter overheats and is damaged

I used to have a faulty connection to one of the spark plugs on a 1989 Opel Vectra. So I know that temporarily running the engine on three cylinders firing won't ruin either the ignition coil or the catalytic converter -- assuming you immediately notice the condition and fix it.

I also once suffered an ignition coil wire disconnection, which obviously stopped the engine. Fortunately was easy thing to fix, in two minutes I was already driving again. This momentary event damaged neither the ignition coil nor the catalytic converter.

However, starting to genuinely drive at a fast speed on a car having one cylinder misfiring could damage the catalytic converter. I understand that new cars automatically detect this condition and stops fuel injection to the misfiring cylinder.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.