Several months ago, my oil and oil filter were changed at Sears. Then all of a sudden my 2015 crv started making a noise. By the time I got home, oil light started flashing on and off occasionaly, not staying on though. Next morning oil puddle on my garage floor. Called and had it towed to dealership to see what was going on. Sears had used a wrench to install oil filter, caused, scratches, dents and crushed oil filter. It is believed this caused a small hole, several months later that caused oil loss. Oil was all gone by time it got to dealership. They changed oil and oil filter. Had oil filter cut open. A few filings in found in oil filter. None found in oil that was put in and drained out, before they actually changed oil filter and oil. Car seems to be running fine now, drove over 1,000 miles. Is there a possibilit my engine was damaged>

1 Answer 1


The big question here is: Did engine damage occur?

The answer: Most definitely.

When an engine is ran without oil or very low oil, lubrication suffers and metal on metal contact of engine parts can occur.

Due to this, the question then becomes: How much damage occurred due to the negligence?

The answer: It is hard to tell.

Without a complete engine teardown and full inspection, there's no way to tell how much damage occurred. Yes, some damage occurred, have no doubt about it. How much did it shorten the engine life of the vehicle? There's no way to know. More than likely only minimal damage has occurred. Better yet, you'll probably never know the difference. The difference may be the engine may last 10k miles less than it would have otherwise (and I'm just throwing numbers out there). The thing is, though, Honda's have a great reputation for longevity. If you continue to take care of your vehicle with proper maintenance, you'll most likely trade the vehicle off before you'll get to the end of your vehicle's lifespan.

The engine would be the only part which might have been affected. Since you were cognizant enough to quit running the vehicle when you noticed a problem, I'm sure only a very minor amount of damage occurred. Again, you'll probably never even notice the difference. Considering the engine now seems to be running just fine, you've most likely avoided a huge repair bill, even if it was some lousy tech's problem. Chalk it up to the tech having a bad day and don't go back there again.

  • If I have my oil and oil filter changed again now, after driving over 1000 miles, had the oil filter cut open and no filings, would that be a sign that the engine didn't get damaged? Thank you
    – slk
    Commented Mar 24, 2017 at 13:10
  • On Top Gear in one episode, they drained the oil out of an engine then started it - it ran for a surprising amount of time before it failed.
    – Solar Mike
    Commented Mar 24, 2017 at 13:11
  • Checking for filings : sadly no, not all the damage will cause filings.
    – Solar Mike
    Commented Mar 24, 2017 at 13:12
  • 1
    Oh and for your information, when you install an oil filter you thread it on hand tight no more. So using a wrench as an automatic fail. Commented Mar 24, 2017 at 14:24
  • 1
    @RowanHawkins - Most suggest 1/4 turn past gasket (o-ring) touchdown, but yes, easily done by hand. What's amazing is even at this low level of torque on the filter, how hard it can be to take off when it's oil change time. Amazing. Commented Mar 24, 2017 at 14:49

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .