2

There is very little information online about the advantages of purchasing an ECU with the highest version alphabet - which means the most upgraded version.

My question is - what kind of benefits come to the purchaser? Are they noticeable? Or are they things you can never notice?

My original ECU is GY04-18-881E but am purchasing GY04-18-881R0H as its replacement

Additional Detail:

A good example of the issue at hand is 2001 - 2003 Toyota Rav 4 ECUs and the destruction of transmissions as a result.

Which was so bad that either the ECU had to be repaired or replaced correctly or the transmission would have to be replaced.

My vehicle is a Mazda MPV 2000 California Emissions with anti-theft model.

if you want to buy that ECU today you cannot find the original part number from Mazda only the updated version, hence i wanted to know what benefits could likely come from purchasing the latest version!

The truth is unless I go to a break yard, I can't even get the original part. I know ECU information is proprietary but in general terms and without breaking any laws or agreements - how do I benefit by purchasing the latest version?

Additional Edit: Here is an ECU change in which a newer version replaced the older version ECU replacing procedures

Additional Information here: Installing a used ECM

If you don't match the part numbers, then you may run into issues with software and hardware revision levels, because I did. Please pay particular attention to the comments by @Kilo:

Blockquote I work in this field. I'm an embedded engineer who writes code for instrument clusters and ECUs.

Blockquote ECM (or ECU) often have stickers on the back of them denoting both a hardware revision level and software revision level. I would make sure both those values match the old module you are replacing or that you have some sort of confirmation that the one you are purchasing is backward compatible.

Blockquote ECU/ECM are essentially single board computers specialized to marshall data on & off a CAN or LIN network - some ECUs are apart of a MOST ring. Depending on what networks (CAN, LIN, MOST, etc...) the hardware & software of the module really determine how compatible the unit will be in your vehicle with other ECUs on the bus.

In particular, the EEPROM on the original PCM was a 77005, the EEPROM on the replacement PCM was 77014, according to the locksmith that was why copying the data over did not result in the car starting. I now have to either source for the exact same part number, or a remanufactured PCM and immobilizer from the dealer at exorbitant cost or try to find an immobilizer emulator to enable me to use the replacement PCM without the additional expense of going the dealer route.

1 Answer 1

5

As a general rule, you should buy the part number specified for your car. Later (higher version alphabet) may not be compatible. If it is compatible it is unlikely you will notice a difference since the ECU changes need to be small enough not to effect any legal compliance they have been certified to meet.

In your specific case the changes could have been minor changes to the maps to improve performance (like smoother idle, not 50 extra HP). Or they could have been related to a design update because some parts became obsolete.

3
  • I ended buying a higher version number ending in H instead of E. One difference is that the old one had 1024kbit space for storing the immobilizer data while the new one had 512kbit, this resulted in some clever programming to get the new ECU to work (recognize keys and immobilizer) without having to purchase a new immobilizer Commented May 5, 2017 at 14:37
  • An aside; but did you post something about that clever programming anywhere? Would love to see it. Commented Jan 10, 2018 at 22:09
  • @InfinitelyManic Vehicle did not start but the DTCs disappeared. Next thing to try is to use As-Built Data and if that fails, then get a PCM without anti-theft, because the cost of going the anti-theft PCM route is enormous Commented Jul 12, 2019 at 9:37

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .