11

The Toyota owner manual contains this diagram.

enter image description here

For non-directional tyres, what is the significance of swapping tyres in this pattern? Specifically, why is it advised to keep the front tyres on the same side of the car when moving them to the rear?

13

Why rotate tires at all?

You probably already know this, but the reason we rotate the tires is to even out the wear and to try to maximize the miles from each set. For that reason, if the vehicle has a full-size spare tire that is also the same size and is also non-directional, it would be included in the rotation. If the vehicle had dual rear wheels (as with some trucks), those would also be included.

Choosing a pattern

For front-wheel drive vehicles (which I am guessing this one is), the front tires wear more than the rear tires. To maximize the use of the tires, we want to try to assure that each tire alternates between high wear and low wear positions. Obviously, the spare tire is the lowest wear, since it's not even touching the ground.

Cross or not cross?

Because the major wear difference is between front an rear, one way to rotate the tires is to simply swap front to rear (ignoring the possibility of a full-size spare). However, there are often noticeable differences in the wear rates of the front right and front left tires (especially for front-wheel drive cars), so if the tires were only swapped front-to-back, one side might wear sooner than the other. The solution is to make sure tires get rotated front to back and side to side as in the left and middle diagrams below.

tire rotation patterns

Note that we probably don't want to cross the tires in both directions (front-to-back and back-to-front, as shown in the right diagram) because then any given tire would only occupy 2 of the possible 4 positions on the vehicle and if there were, for example, a wear differential front left and front right (as there is for many front wheel drive cars), one pair of tires would wear more than the other.

A particular pattern

Given only four tires (ignoring the spare again), then it makes sense, given the above, to swap from front to back and from side to side, but two ways this could be done, would be to move the front tires straight back and then cross the rears on their way front (as is shown in your diagram) or to move the rears straight forward and swap the fronts on their way back. Which is better?

The dark secret

The answer to the rhetorical question above is that it really doesn't matter, as long as the pattern is applied consistently. If you chose a pattern each time, you might not remember the last way you'd rotated them, but if you and all previous and all future owners follow the pattern in the manual, the consistent use of the same pattern will maximize tire mileage over the life of the vehicle.

  • Your answer is good, it made me think of something else that I think should be added to this for completeness. By following this pattern, each tyre will be mounted in every position on the vehicle throughout its life, whereas crossing will mean a particular tyre will only ever be used in two positions, and this may result in uneven wear due to parking habits, driving habits, minor alignment issues and weight distribution. Let's ignore the spare as many cars have alloy wheels but steel spare, emergency use spare or no spare at all. – DizzyFool Dec 27 '16 at 8:05
  • 1
    I've added a bit to my answer to address that. – Edward Dec 27 '16 at 16:15
  • +1. And yes you were correct in guessing it is a FWD vehicle. – DizzyFool Dec 27 '16 at 18:24
  • I added some "art" to try to make it pretty. :) – Edward Dec 27 '16 at 20:11
3

The idea behind that pattern is that it tends to distribute the wear more evenly over the surface of the tire if there are minor alignment errors. I don't think there is any reason to keep the front tire on the same side of the car, except that it might result in a bit less movement of the tires from one side to the other.

1

It is about tire wear but I have not seen the issue that causes the undesirable wear addressed in the previous answers. The uneven wear that is being addressed with cross rotation is caused by normal 'Braking'.

Low air pressure, incorrect toe or camber will cause various tire wear problems that will not be corrected by rotation. Proper air pressure, alignment specifications and vehicle loading is the only thing that will effect these types of wear. So a straight to back rotation will be as helpful as a cross pattern.

The simplest way to determine if your tires have wear caused by braking is to run your hand around the circumference of the tire. Standing (or kneeling) by the left front tire, run your hand around the tire in a clockwise direction while focusing on the outer edge, then run your hand in a counter clockwise direction. If the counterclockwise direction feels smooth and the clockwise direction feels rough or jagged this is the wear I'm talking about and the type of wear that will be corrected by cross rotation. This wear also makes the tires very loud. Ever hear a car or truck driving down the road and it has a high speed roaring sound. 4 wheel drive trucks are bad about this due to weight and tire design.

Think about what happens when you apply your brakes. The mass of the vehicle is moving forward and the tire is rotating forward. When you apply the brakes think of the 'wheel' going backwards!!! Obviously this is exaggerated but will help you visualize what is happening. (this is where a picture would be worth a 1000 words.) If you were able to see this you would see the sidewall of the tire twist in a clockwise direction as the tread is still moving in a counterclockwise direction. This twisting motion pulls the front of the individual lugs on the tire, maybe 1/3, out of contact with the road, getting no wear. The remaining 2/3' of the lug is still in contact with the road and will wear. This is the jagged edge you feel running your hand around the tire.

So why cross rotate. Moving the tire to the opposite side of the vehicle reverses the direction of rotation of the. So now those little high spots on each individual lug on the tire will be worn down because they will now be in contact with the road surface during braking. This is also the reason you cannot cross rotate a directional tire.

This problem is more prevalent on front wheel drive vehicles due to the high percentage of front brake bias. Tire design also plays a roll. Think of a passenger car tire with small tightly spaced lugs as compared to a mud and snow tread with large widely spaced lugs. If the wear is severe you may want to cross rotate the fronts only, to accelerate the wear that will bring them back smooth and then do a front to rear rotate.

Gentle braking and proper air pressure will help to minimize this type of wear.

  • I'm not sure this answer addresses the question. Things like "gentle braking" don't really have anything to do with the rationale behind specific tyre rotation patterns and the benefits of different patterns. We aren't seeking to "minimise" tyre wear with this question, rather understand the reasoning behind the rotation pattern given by the owner manual for non-direction tyres. – DizzyFool Dec 27 '16 at 18:20
  • @DizzyFool: The point is that even if a car were perfectly aligned so that the wheels on both sides of the car wore identically, the wear on each wheel would still be non-symmetric in the fore/aft direction. Moving a tire from one side of the car to the other will change which direction faces forward, thus balancing out the wear on that individual tire. – supercat Dec 27 '16 at 19:18
  • Perhaps the question is not clear. We understand that each tyre will not wear symmetrically, the question is to do with the rotation pattern. – DizzyFool Dec 27 '16 at 20:14
0

The reason to keep the tires on one side is

  • to reduce the steel belt stretches in different direction when doing cross rotation. It might lead to premature tire failure.
  • It is not recommended for high speed and high load car.

I do agree that cross rotation make tire wear more even for non-directional tires.

0

The pattern has been carefully selected to obtain these three features:

  1. Front and rear are exchanged and left and right are exchanged
  2. Each tire will visit all possible positions
  3. The tires on the same axle will after rotation be in the same axle again (although this time, the axle is the front if it used to be the rear, and vice versa)

I don't think any existing answer underlines the point (3).

Point (3) is important, because sometimes a tire gets damaged and identical replacement cannot be found. Then the two tires on the same axle will both be replaced. It is possible to run mixed tires, as long as they are not in the same axle.

For directional tires, the pattern is to just swap front and rear, without ever swapping left and right.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.