I know that they are out of production and only a few of them were made.

For 5 cylinder engines...

  • Do they have uneven power delivery?
  • Would two cylinders share a part of the revolution to the crank at the same time and then for the cycle right after it, there would only be one cylinder firing?

For 3 cylinder engines like in the BMW i8...

  • Is there a complete crank revolution without a cylinder firing?
  • How does it not have a very uneven torque delivery? (disregarding the use of the electric motor)
  • 1
    I don't think they are out of production, the Audi RS3 has a 5 cylinder engine
    – BadAtMaths
    Oct 29 '16 at 9:06

You are thinking too linearly. A V8 engine has two connecting rods attached at each crank journal with a crank spacing of 90° between each crank journal. The I5 (like the GM LLR) has a single connecting rod per crank journal and has them separated evenly at 72°. It fires once every 144° of crankshaft rotation. It fires the cylinder a little farther apart, but it's still even between each ignition cycle. In some ways it's even a bit smoother than a V8 would be because it has an inherent power cycle overlap of 36° which you don't get in a V8, V6, or I4 engine.

Here is an drawing of how the crankshaft would look from the end position:

enter image description here

Here is a great animated image of the 5-cyl in motion. (NOTE: The image was a tad to big and Imgur wouldn't accept it.)

This Engineering Explained Video does a great job of explaining the 5-cyl engine.

The I3 engine (and there are plenty of them which have been made) has the cylinder separation at 120° and fires every 240°. This is a larger separation and would have more vibration. The power cycles are also spaced further apart, pretty much like a V6 engine, at 120° between each firing. With this, there is a dead space between each where no power stroke is occurring.

Here's a great animation of a 3-cyl engine in operation:

enter image description here

This Engineering Explained Video does a great job of explaining the 3-cyl engine.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.